Australia’s controversial plans to reduce the population of sharks in surrounding seas entailed of very little thought and high fear-mongering tactics.

The cull was an attempt to protect beach-goers from potential attack, but was this a largely Jaws-inspired fear campaign that wasn’t properly thought through?

Do sharks actually pose a threat to Australians?

Even though the Australian media constantly alarms the threat of shark attacks to swimmers and beach-dwellers, the figures never match the claim.

According to the Australian Shark Attack File (ASAF), sharks have killed 52 people in the past 50 years (so, roughly one per year) in Australian waters. 172 sharks were killed in Western Australia in 2014.

Considering how dramatic the increase in swimmers and the population has been in recent years, these statistics reflect that a threat is not posed by swimmers in THE SHARK’s water.

The government statistics bureau states that shark attacks are so infrequent that you are far more likely to be accidentally suffocated in bed.

Western Australia’s population > shark attack ratio is a major factor in proving that these supposedly “man-eating monsters” need to be maintained. 2016 proved that there were fewer shark-related fatalities than the previous year according to EarthSky.

The idea of “decreasing” fatalities is plain and simple. Take some cars off the road and naturally, you will reduce the amount of road accidents. However, this doesn’t mean that people won’t be killed.

How do they actually cull sharks in Australia? A helicopter – fixed with a shark radar — hovers above the shark hotspots (and wherever the radar tells them to) and should the “culler” spot one, and then a spear gun is used to fire a 17-inch spear into the back of its head.

This makes me question why the government would declare the great white shark (supposedly the main tyrant) a ‘vulnerable species’ and yet still insist on killing them off in order to maintain safer beaches. There has never been a recorded incident in the last 60 years of a shark intentionally swimming to shallow waters to attack an unsuspecting human.

In an interesting standpoint; estimates show that the average of bee-sting related DEATHS are much much higher on Earth than shark attacks.

Once more, researchers claim you are far more-likely to be killed by the weather than ripped to shreds by a six metre diamond-toothed shark.

So is Australia on a vengeance to kill sharks? And what do we do if it doesn’t bring the number of one death per year down to 0?

The Western Australia cull stopped in 2014 and since then there have been plenty of surfers supporting new measures to ‘protect’ them.

Please consider donating

We are 100% independent and therefore we have no paid-for-comment financial support from commercial entities or political groups. We strive to be as free as possible. We won't implement paywalls or subscription programs. Your donations are incredibly helpful and help keep us alive. You can donate through PayPal, Patreon or Bitcoin as well as support us by buying TWS merchandise.


Leave a Reply

10 Comments on "The Australian Shark Cull – Has It Helped?"

Leave a Reply

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

Australia is obviously overreacting to the threat of shark attacks. Numbers don’t lie.

Kyo Kusagi

We cannot blame sharks for this. One they are animals that are only acting to their instinct and two it is us that are in their domain. That is why its people who are warned to stay away not the shark for we are higher than they are,


They are sea creatures. It is always a human responsibility to foresee danger or accident in the place. Like taking some precautionary measures.

Raphael Fabella

As far as i know, sharks don’t usually go near shallow waters. I don’t think sharks pose that much of a threat to beach goers. Maybe it’s the fear from the media (like Jaws and other sea monster movies) that give people this type of fear.


Yup! Media propaganda will do it! It will instill false fears in the minds of people without sound evidence to back it up. Then people will scramble hastily to do stuff not even understanding why their doing it. Like robots or something. Sometimes I wonder…are people really smarter than other animals? To me, it really depends on how you look at it.

Ricardo Ramirez

I wouldn´t want to meet face to face with a shark, but I wouldn´t want them to be kiiled either. There must be a better method of keeping sharks away from crowded beaches. I hope someone finds another method to keep keep people safe from these sea animals.


“This makes me question why the government would declare the great white shark (supposedly the main tyrant) a ‘vulnerable species’” What I think that, it might good for government to protect wild animal. At the same time, government might also set up policies to protect human lives.


It was a knee-jerk reaction. And definitely not a very wise decision. They should’ve explored other options to calm down the public.


The paranoia is probably caused by too much watching of Jaws, Deep Blue Sea, Sharknado, and the likes. As natural predators, it is easy to depict them as dangerous creatures. I mean, with all this tech around, can’t anyone make some sort of scanner that can monitor or detect shark presence? With such a device, human-shark encounter can definitely be reduced or eliminated.

Patricia G.

These sharks are just protecting their territory. The sea waters are their domain, not ours. We must respect that and navigate accordingly.